Nursing Home
Montello Care Center
Part of Wisconsin Illinois Senior Housing, Inc.see all 10 affiliated facilities
Medicare Outcome Measures
- No Different than the National Rate
Potentially preventable hospital readmissions
11.09% (lower is better)
- No Different than the National Rate
Residents discharged back to the community
59.96% (higher is better)
- No Different than the National Rate
Infections acquired during the stay requiring hospitalization
7.80% (lower is better)
Source: CMS Skilled Nursing Facility Quality Reporting Program. Rates are risk-standardized by CMS; the comparison category is CMS's own, shown exactly as published.
Clinical Quality Measures
-
Long-stay residents with a urinary tract infection
5.1%
national median 0.9%
worse than the national median
-
Long-stay residents experiencing falls with major injury
0.0%
national median 2.8%
better than the national median
-
Short-stay residents who newly received an antipsychotic medication
2.5%
national median 1.0%
worse than the national median
-
Long-stay residents with pressure ulcers
10.0%
national median 4.2%
worse than the national median
-
Long-stay residents who received an antipsychotic medication
14.7%
national median 13.4%
near the national median
Source: CMS MDS quality measures (four-quarter average).
Nurse Staffing
- Nursing staff turnover in the past year
- 64.0%
WI average: 46.9% · National: 45.8%
Share of this facility’s nursing staff who stopped working there over 12 months.
Reported by facilities through CMS's Payroll-Based Journal system. Facility values and the state/national averages are shown exactly as CMS publishes them. More staffing hours are generally better; lower turnover is generally better.
Penalties & Enforcement
2 fines totaling $142,634 in the recent inspection window (most recent: October 22, 2025).
Federal enforcement actions from CMS's penalty file: civil money penalties (fines) and denials of Medicare payment tied to health-inspection deficiencies.
Ownership
- Ownership type
- Non profit - Corporation
- Chain
- Wisconsin Illinois Senior Housing, Inc.
Who owns this facility — 11 entries in CMS's ownership records expand ↓
- Burke, Dana Individual
- Dupont, Lori Individual
- Gehler, Miriam Individual
- Gerlach, Keri Individual
- Kerwin, Andrew Individual
- Kumar, Rajeev Shiva Individual
- Lacke (carrig), Karen Individual
- Lynn, Nicholas Individual
- Sherman, Stephanie Individual
- Carriage Healthcare Companies Inc Organization
…and 1 more entry in CMS's ownership records for this facility.
From CMS's nursing-home ownership file. Roles and percentages are as reported to CMS by the facility; one person or entity can hold several roles.
Inspections & Fire Safety — 25 health (WI avg 9.5) · 10 fire (WI avg 5.9) · ⚠ 3 serious Details
68 deficiencies cited across recent inspection cycles, including ⚠ 3 serious (actual harm or immediate jeopardy). Most recent survey: June 8, 2026.
Most recent inspection cycle: 25 health deficiencies · WI average: 9.5 · National: 9.3
31 fire-safety deficiencies cited — most often smoke (11) and gas, vacuum, and electrical systems (8).
Most recent fire-safety inspection (2025-12-04): 10 deficiencies · WI average: 5.9 · National: 4.5
Sources: CMS health inspection reports (standard surveys and complaint investigations) and CMS Life Safety Code inspections (smoke barriers, sprinklers, exits, emergency preparedness). Averages are CMS-published state and national figures for the most recent inspection cycle.
Is this your organization?
Claim this listing free to add your logo, correct details, and publish a statement.
How Montello Care Center compares nearby
Compared with the 5 other nursing homes within 25 miles — 6 facilities in all, CMS data only.
Among the 6 nursing homes within 25 miles, Montello Care Center's overall star rating is 1★; the median among the 5 peers reporting it is 4★.
| Measure | This facility | Nearby median |
|---|---|---|
| Overall star rating reported by 5 of 5 nearby peers | 1★ | 4★ |
| Health inspections reported by 5 of 5 nearby peers | 1★ | 4★ |
| Staffing reported by 5 of 5 nearby peers | 1★ | 5★ |
| Quality measures reported by 5 of 5 nearby peers | 2★ | 4★ |
The comparison group
- Markesan Resident Home
- Columbia Health Care Center
- Wisconsin Dells Health Services
- Randolph Health Services
- Juliette Manor
Cohort: within 25 miles · CMS data period 2026-08 · method cohort-v1 · comparisons are never affected by claiming or payment. How nearby comparisons work