Nursing Home

Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community

11230 State Route 364, St Marys, OH 45885

Part of Otterbein Seniorlifesee all 20 affiliated facilities

53 certified beds 50 residents per day on average Continuing Care Retirement Community

CMS Five-Star Quality Rating

4 out of 5 Stars

Overall rating

Health inspections

From the three most recent annual inspection cycles and recent complaint investigations.

Staffing

Based on nurse staffing hours relative to the care needs of this facility’s residents.

Quality measures

Based on clinical quality measures reported for residents, from assessments and Medicare claims.

Source: CMS Five-Star Quality Rating System. These are CMS's own ratings, shown exactly as published — CareRanks does not adjust or re-weight them. How CMS calculates these ratings ↗

Medicare Outcome Measures

Source: CMS Skilled Nursing Facility Quality Reporting Program. Rates are risk-standardized by CMS; the comparison category is CMS's own, shown exactly as published.

Clinical Quality Measures

Source: CMS MDS quality measures (four-quarter average).

Nurse Staffing

Nurse staffing per resident per day
3.5 hours

OH average: 3.7 hours · National: 3.9 hours

All nursing staff combined: RNs, LPNs/LVNs, and nurse aides.

Registered nurse (RN) time per resident per day
0.8 hours

OH average: 0.6 hours · National: 0.7 hours

RN hours only — the most highly trained nursing staff.

Weekend nurse staffing per resident per day
3.1 hours

OH average: 3.3 hours · National: 3.4 hours

Total nurse staffing on Saturdays and Sundays, when staffing typically dips.

Nursing staff turnover in the past year
34.0%

OH average: 48.7% · National: 45.8%

Share of this facility’s nursing staff who stopped working there over 12 months.

Reported by facilities through CMS's Payroll-Based Journal system. Facility values and the state/national averages are shown exactly as CMS publishes them. More staffing hours are generally better; lower turnover is generally better.

Ownership

Ownership type
For profit - Corporation
Chain
Otterbein Seniorlife
Who owns this facility — 25 entries in CMS's ownership records expand ↓
  • Otterbein Lsc LLC Organization
    Direct owner (≥5%) 100% ownership since 01/01/2016
  • Otterbein Home Organization
    Indirect owner (≥5%) 100% ownership since 12/01/2021
  • Borns, Deborah Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 01/01/2017
  • Coffin, Gordon Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 01/01/2023
  • Dues, Steve Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 01/01/2013
  • Gamble, Charles Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 07/01/2014
  • Imwalle, Karen Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 01/01/2025
  • Ingraham, Jeffrey Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 01/01/2024
  • Kroeger, Tyler Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 01/01/2025
  • Steinemann, Jane Individual
    Managing control (governing body) since 12/01/2021

…and 15 more entries in CMS's ownership records for this facility.

From CMS's nursing-home ownership file. Roles and percentages are as reported to CMS by the facility; one person or entity can hold several roles.

Inspections & Fire Safety — 4 health (OH avg 10.7) · 7 fire (OH avg 5.8) · ⚠ 1 serious Details

24 deficiencies cited across recent inspection cycles, including ⚠ 1 serious (actual harm or immediate jeopardy). Most recent survey: April 3, 2024.

Most recent inspection cycle: 4 health deficiencies · OH average: 10.7 · National: 9.3

14 fire-safety deficiencies cited — most often smoke (6) and egress (3).

Most recent fire-safety inspection (2023-09-14): 7 deficiencies · OH average: 5.8 · National: 4.5

Sources: CMS health inspection reports (standard surveys and complaint investigations) and CMS Life Safety Code inspections (smoke barriers, sprinklers, exits, emergency preparedness). Averages are CMS-published state and national figures for the most recent inspection cycle.

Is this your organization?

Claim this listing free to add your logo, correct details, and publish a statement.

Claim this listing

How Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community compares nearby

Compared with the 8 other nursing homes within 25 miles — 9 facilities in all, CMS data only.

Among the 9 nursing homes within 25 miles, Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community's overall star rating is 4★; the median among the 8 peers reporting it is 4★.

Measure This facility Nearby median Best nearby
Overall star rating reported by 8 of 8 nearby peers 4★ 4★ 5★
Health inspections reported by 8 of 8 nearby peers 4★ 4★ 5★
Staffing reported by 8 of 8 nearby peers 3★ 3★ 4★
Quality measures reported by 8 of 8 nearby peers 4★ 4★ 5★

The comparison group

Cohort: within 25 miles · CMS data period 2026-08 · method cohort-v1 · comparisons are never affected by claiming or payment. How nearby comparisons work

Compare this nursing home with another →